1. Prepare cake batter as directed on package. Add dry pudding mix; mix well. Spoon into 24 paper-lined muffin cups. Bake as directed on package for cupcakes; cool completely. 2. Beat cream cheese, butter and vanilla in medium bowl with mixer until blended. Gradually beat in sugar. Spread onto cupcakes. 3. Decorate with remaining ingredients to resemble "eyeballs."
* Substitute: Prepare using your favorite flavor of cake mix.